IHB OpenIR  > 水生生物多样性与资源保护研究中心  > 期刊论文
Different surrogacy approaches for stream macroinvertebrates in discriminating human disturbances in Central China
Jiang, Xiaoming1; Song, Zhuoyan1,2; Xiong, Jing1; Proctor, Heather2; Xie, Zhicai1
2017-04-01
Source PublicationECOLOGICAL INDICATORS
ISSN1470-160X
Volume75Issue:1Pages:182-191
Abstract

Due to the difficulty of identifying many taxa of freshwater invertebrates to species, many researchers have assessed the utility of surrogates for species-level identifications (e.g. higher taxa) in bioassessment programs. Here, we examined the efficiency of two different approaches to species surrogacy, one using coarser taxonomic resolution and a second approach based on random aggregation ("Best practicable aggregation of species", BestAgg), in portraying patterns of stream macroinvertebrates in Central China. The main objectives were: (1) to compare the discriminatory power of biodiversity indices and assemblage structure for different levels of human disturbances based on different taxonomic resolution and on BestAgg; (2) to identify the congruence of assemblage-environment and biodiversity-indicesenvironment relationships for datasets at the species level versus those at surrogate levels. We found that genus-level and BestAgg datasets accurately reproduced the pattern of species-level communities, whereas family-and order-level datasets did not. Specifically, both genus-level and BestAgg approaches performed almost as well as species-level data in distinguishing sites subjected to different disturbance levels. Most of the environmental variables that were important for species-level assemblages, also emerged as significant when analyzing genera and BestAgg surrogates, as shown by both analyses of indices and assemblage composition according to distance-based ordination models. Our results suggest that genus-level taxonomy, which resulted in the least loss of ecological information relative to species-level identification, is sufficient in studies of community ecology and bioassessment of stream macroinvertebrates in Central China. In addition, the BestAgg approach, which required identification of fewer taxa than genus-level analysis, has a similar ability to depict multivariate patterns of macroinvertebrate assemblages and differentiate different disturbance levels. Applying our results could enhance speed and cost-effectiveness of freshwater biomonitoring and bioassessment programs; however, independent determination of best taxonomic level and BestAgg will be required whenever a new geographic area or habitat type is assessed. (C) 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

KeywordSpecies surrogacy Stream macroinvertebrates Community composition Biodiversity indices Random aggregation Bioassessment
DOI10.1016/j.ecolind.2016.12.039
Funding OrganizationNational Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project
Indexed BySCI
Language英语
Funding ProjectNational Natural Science Foundation of China[31400469] ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program[2015FY110400-4] ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project[JGJ/0272015]
WOS Research AreaBiodiversity & Conservation ; Environmental Sciences & Ecology
WOS SubjectBiodiversity Conservation ; Environmental Sciences
WOS IDWOS:000398334600020
WOS KeywordTAXONOMIC RESOLUTION ; SPECIES SURROGACY ; MULTIVARIATE-ANALYSIS ; CHIRONOMID COMMUNITY ; BESTAGG APPROACH ; BETA DIVERSITY ; SUFFICIENCY ; TAXA ; CONSERVATION ; PATTERNS
PublisherELSEVIER SCIENCE BV
Funding OrganizationNational Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; National Science and Technology Basic Research Program ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project ; China Three Gorges Corporation Research Project
Citation statistics
Cited Times:4[WOS]   [WOS Record]     [Related Records in WOS]
Document Type期刊论文
Identifierhttp://ir.ihb.ac.cn/handle/342005/32775
Collection水生生物多样性与资源保护研究中心_期刊论文
Corresponding AuthorXie, Zhicai
Affiliation1.Chinese Acad Sci, Inst Hydrobiol, CAS Key Lab Aquat Biodivers & Conservat, Wuhan 430072, Peoples R China
2.Univ Alberta, Dept Biol Sci, Edmonton, AB, Canada
Recommended Citation
GB/T 7714
Jiang, Xiaoming,Song, Zhuoyan,Xiong, Jing,et al. Different surrogacy approaches for stream macroinvertebrates in discriminating human disturbances in Central China[J]. ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS,2017,75(1):182-191.
APA Jiang, Xiaoming,Song, Zhuoyan,Xiong, Jing,Proctor, Heather,&Xie, Zhicai.(2017).Different surrogacy approaches for stream macroinvertebrates in discriminating human disturbances in Central China.ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS,75(1),182-191.
MLA Jiang, Xiaoming,et al."Different surrogacy approaches for stream macroinvertebrates in discriminating human disturbances in Central China".ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS 75.1(2017):182-191.
Files in This Item: Download All
File Name/Size DocType Version Access License
1-s2.0-S1470160X1630(1834KB)期刊论文出版稿开放获取CC BY-NC-SAView Download
Related Services
Recommend this item
Bookmark
Usage statistics
Export to Endnote
Google Scholar
Similar articles in Google Scholar
[Jiang, Xiaoming]'s Articles
[Song, Zhuoyan]'s Articles
[Xiong, Jing]'s Articles
Baidu academic
Similar articles in Baidu academic
[Jiang, Xiaoming]'s Articles
[Song, Zhuoyan]'s Articles
[Xiong, Jing]'s Articles
Bing Scholar
Similar articles in Bing Scholar
[Jiang, Xiaoming]'s Articles
[Song, Zhuoyan]'s Articles
[Xiong, Jing]'s Articles
Terms of Use
No data!
Social Bookmark/Share
File name: 1-s2.0-S1470160X16307440-main.pdf
Format: Adobe PDF
All comments (0)
No comment.
 

Items in the repository are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.